Civil Society's Role in Ensuring the Public Accountability of the United Nations
Global catastrophic risk mitigated
Unknown risks
Risk multiplier managed
Institutions that lack inclusivity or accountability
Implementation timeframe
Short term
As CSOs created the momentum for the ICC; as CSO’s demands for justice for the victims of SEA in CAR exposed the extent of the situation; as CSOs revealed IHL/IHRL violations of UN personnel deployed in PKOs, the CSOs now ad hoc public accountability role should be organized and mobilized proactively.
Implementation strategy

CSO action holding the UN accountable is already happening on an ad hoc basis. CSO efforts should be organized and mobilized proactively to provide constant and consistent public accountability for UN action or inaction. Based on their areas of competence and interest, CSO's can be identified to take lead on monitoring areas of concern:

- SEA
- Past IHL/IHRL Violations for Human Rights Screening
- Ongoing IHL/IHRL Violations
- Financial Corruption
- Victims' rights"

Political will exists to realise this proposal

While the UN has its own oversight bodies and conduct and discipline units (at HQ and in the field) for cases of individual misconduct, the bigger picture of the Organization's own accountability often goes unaccounted for in the face of apathy by Member States.

What if political will does not exist yet

The promise is made, the aspiration is oft repeated; the obligation is codified but the implementation is lacking and requires external pressure.

Mitigating unknown risks

The lack of public accountability contributes to the erosion of the credibility and effectiveness of the Organization and undermines its ability to fulfill its mandates. Ensuring such accountability could therefore restore the credibility of the Organization and its adherence to its own values and principles. Public accountability will ultimately make the UN more effective - not only as a more credible advocate for human rights and the rule of law but also as an operational actor on the ground - as a peacemaker and peacekeeper.

Reducing inclusivity and accountability in national and global governance

No.

Conversing effect of increasing conflict and political violence

There is a risk that increased criticism and condemnation of UN failures and violations could further undermine the credibility and effectiveness of the UN in the short term. Failure to ensure such accountability, however, will exact far greater damage in the medium- to long-term.

Enhancing inclusivity and accountability in national and global governance

As elaborated above, the proposal is all about accountability for UN action and inaction.

The more organized and mobilized the CSO community is in ensuring constant and consistent public accountability and exposing acts of omission as well as acts of commission, and the more aware and responsive to such accountability the Organization is, the more credible and effective it will be.

Raising the cost and increasing the reputational risk of the Organization will in the medium term incentivize the Organization to internalize and regularize doing the right thing on its own - if only to preempt or to avoid the public accounting.

“Those who seek to bestow legitimacy must themselves embody it, and those who invoke international law must themselves submit to it.” United Nations Secretary-General Kofi Annan at the 59th session of the UN General Assembly on 22 September 2004.

Additional information

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coalition_for_the_International_Criminal_Court

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/mar/31/united-nations-widens-sex-abuse-inquiry-peacekeepers-central-african-republic-car

Other ideas you might be interested in
Published by Cristina Petcu Unknown risks
Create a strong UN Peacebuilding Council to replace the current Peacebuilding Commission
Similar to the transformation of the Human Rights Commission into a Council, it is time for the UN Peacebuilding Commission to be upgraded into a Council with enhanced powers and responsibilities; and mandated to lead on policy development, coordinat...
Published by Richard Alexander Shirres Climate change, Eco-system collapse, Unknown risks
Scheme to accredit 'UN Global Eco-Steward Champions' status to active citizens
Contribution to global governance - Purpose: To expand and develop advocacy of the UN’s work in relation to global ecological stewardship and raise awareness of this crucial but lesser appreciated role of the UN and, thereby, advance support for the...
Published by Richard Maxheim The threat from new and emerging technology
UN sovereignty in Affairs of Mankind
A more effective UN needs its own sovereignty. This can be created if member states surrender certain parts of their national sovereignty. The sovereignty of the UN should be limited to affairs of mankind. For this, the affairs of mankind would have...
Published by Arthur Lyon Dahl Climate change, Eco-system collapse, Pandemics and anti-microbial resistance, The threat from new and emerging technology, Unknown risks
Governance, Science and the Climate Crisis
For climate and other catastrophic risks, science is the foundation for public education, policy-making and action, requiring strengthening formal science-policy inputs to UN and government decision-making, while building public support for action as...
Published by Arthur Lyon Dahl Climate change, Eco-system collapse, Pandemics and anti-microbial resistance, Weapons of Mass Destruction, The threat from new and emerging technology, Unknown risks
Global Governance and the Emergence of Global Institutions for the 21st Century
Our book "Global Governance and the Emergence of Global Institutions for the 21st Century" will initiate wide dialogue on the future of global governance, presenting a package of core UN reforms to modernize the current global governance system to re...